Monday, July 11, 2011

How Much is Enough?


Mary Sullivan


In the first week of August, I will be attending the RomCon reader’s convention in Denver. I attended last year and had a ball. This year, I’ve been invited back as a featured author, which means I'll be involved in events that require me to provide promo materials.


This is the first time in my writing career I’ve actually had promotional material printed—bookmarks with the names of my published books on the back as well as the names of July's and November's releases, so each one is a large business card with my print list on it, and postcards with one of my original recipes printed on the front, rather than a current book cover which would render the postcards obsolete too quickly. Ditto for putting a book cover image on the bookmarks. The postcards will go on the goody table for all attendees to pick up if they want.


However, neither of these is really much of a promotional item to put in the goody bags that will be handed out at certain events. Usually an author will put in any books the publisher will send along. When I started planning for this convention, though, the only stock that Harlequin would have available would be my July release, BEYOND ORDINARY. This caused a conflict with the booksigning that RomCon had planned. That would be the book that RomCon would hope readers would purchase and have signed.


So…I had to come up with promo ideas for events with large attendee lists, like 100 and 75. That’s a lot of items. Have you ever taken a look at how expensive customized note pads and sticky notes are? On VistaPrint, whose prices are fairly reasonable, they’re four and five dollars a piece. I’m afraid it’s too much for me.


I also worried about how many items would actually ever be used. I mean, how many key chains can one person use? So, are some things a waste of money and materials?


I had to become really creative…I mean REALLY creative. At a local cookie outlet, I bought boxes of small packages of these fabulous cranberry cookies then printed my own labels—Mary Sullivan, Harlequin Superromance, website URL--and stuck them to the cookies. Total cost? Sixteen cents a piece.


Then I had an idea that had me laughing. I decided to shred my very first manuscript, which was rejected everywhere, and made paper out of it in my blender. I added red tissue paper to turn the homemade paper pink then shaped it into hearts to which I added flower seeds. The recipient can break the paper heart into pieces and plant it and grow flowers. At least someone would get some use out of that old manuscript ;-)


I decided that the seeds to add would be Morning Glories, because the first romance novel I ever read was LaVyrle Spencer’s MORNING GLORY, and it inspired me to write romance. This took on sentimental significance for me because it was my mother who recommended that I should read it. At the time, I actually said to her, “I don’t read romance novels,” and she replied, “You’ll love this story,” and I did. I gobbled up the rest of LaVyrle Spencer’s novels and started writing. I've read a lot of romance ever since. My mother died last year, but I know she would have appreciated the whimsy of these hearts.


So, I have a couple of hundred hearts that I’m bringing to the convention.


Borders has since had to pull out of having a book sale and booksigning at the convention, so Harlequin might be able to provide July’s book, if there is stock available.


Even if books are available, I’ll bring along my cookies and hearts and hand them out anyway.


To all of you readers, what do you expect in the way of promotional items when you attend conferences and conventions, or author teas, or any sort of author event, and receive goody bags? Would one pen in the bottom of a goody bag be enough from one author? But the pens that are reasonably priced are…pretty cheaply made and disposable so, again, a waste of materials.


To the authors on the loop, how do you handle this situation? Both the readers and the convention expect us to provide SOMETHING. But what is the sense in spending more per item than we make on the sale of each book? First time I’ve faced this problem. It’s been interesting to solve.


I’d like to give away two copies of BEYOND ORDINARY.


MORE QUESTIONS: I'm adding questions here that I forgot to include when I wrote up this blog last night! Which type of promo item prompts you to buy an author's book? Where are promo dollars effective? ARE they effective?

44 comments:

Anita Joy said...

Mary, love your creative ideas. Definite advantages because they will stand out from the regular promo material.

I use the pens and the sticky notes, but have a drawer overflowing with bookmarks.

I like to get those little books of excerpts (you know the sort, often have the first chapter of an upcoming release). I've bought new authors after reading their chapter - and I found these are great for the flight home after conference.

marybelle said...

I absolutely love the idea of the recycled manuscript, seed embedded hearts. I would remember these. I love useful & creative.

linda s said...

Hi Mary, conferences are such fun. Your pink hearts are a great idea. I'd enjoy your cookies. I'm a great fan of personalized pencils and fridge magnets of all types.
Due to the mail strike, I just got my copy of Beyond Ordinary today and look forward to reading it this week.

Babs said...

Love the goodies you came up with...very original and would definitely get my attention.

Honestly, I have a stack of bookmarks that I don't really pay attention to and a pen would just get claimed by my daughter for one of her 'projects' and disappear.

msullivan said...

Anita Joy, I love excerpt booklets, too. They really whet the appetite for reading the entire book. Questions I forgot to ask in the blog are, which type of promo item prompts you to buy an author's book? Where are promo dollars effective? ARE they effective?

msullivan said...

Marybelle, I'm so glad you like the idea of the hearts. I LOVE recycling, so the idea of the recycled manuscript really appealed to me, as well as being whimsical and different.

msullivan said...

Linda, I'm so happy the book finally arrived! A little late, but still in time for summer reading ;-)

msullivan said...

Babs, I'm rethinking the bookmarks and wondering whether they were worth the money, but they do have the list of my books on the back, so I'm still hoping they'll be useful for readers.

Kimber Chin said...

I LOVE the heart idea. SO creative and so significant.

I love pens as schwag. I use them. People borrow them (or steal them). I figure if banks have to chain up pens, they must be something folks want.

I obtain mine through National Pens and they are $0.10 each or something low like that.

For bigger prizes, I like receiving t-shirts. Every time I wear the t-shirt (and I wear them for years), I'm advertising for the author.

BTW... Mary, I'm so excited re: your success. You are a warm, generous person, and you truly deserve the best! (Plus your talent... wow, your talent!)

Laney4 said...

I use the pens and HAVE noticed they don't last long. I like to replace the ink from other pens and then hand out to friends so that I can keep the author's name "out there". One I particularly like has purple ink and is more like a felt marker, and it has lasted me (and my Sudoku puzzle books) months (from Barbara Dunlop). It says Pilot G-2 07 on its clip....

I use and pass on bookmarks (as sometimes I receive a bunch of them at a time). I don't feel guilty (any more) when they wear out, as I know I have been reading lots to get them in that condition.

I have won a few tote bags, which I use when grocery shopping, and it sure causes discussion at the checkout lineups, let me tell you! They are more expensive, but they are bigger, so they are noticed more easily outside the home.

I use the post-its but have also shared these with friends IF I notice that they would like them. I don't use the fridge magnets on my fridge (my fridge is cluttered enough already), but I will use them as bookmarks instead. My husband uses the emery boards. I use a mug with an author's name and current book on it (for my pens/pencils on my desk). I don't use the luggage tags. My girlfriends use the sachets of potpourri, tiny perfume bottles, and soaps, as I'm allergic/sensitive to so many things. I always eat the chocolate, but I've been known to share, especially with my husband. I give away the coffee because I don't drink it.

I've been pretty blessed, as you can tell. Good luck!

msullivan said...

Kimber, hi! It was great to see you on Saturday, even if so briefly.

I'll have to rethink the pen issue, and a t-shirt in a prize tote would be a great idea!

Thank you for your kind words. They mean a lot. Seriously. I'm prone to the worst doubts about my writing! Eeeek.

msullivan said...

Laney, you've received a LOT of promo items! I really appreciate your feedback on what works for you and what doesn't.

I just looked up the Pilot G-2 07. It looks like the type of pen I would like to have!

I thought of potpourri sachets, but was worried about allergies.

JV said...

Mary, I love the idea of the heart and the cookie treat in general! They're very clever, and both would be items that people would be glad to have, I'd think. I'm not sure how well they'd work for purposes of promotion, however, other than to promote good will toward the author because once the cookies are gone and the box discarded and once the heart is planted, there's no tie-in to the author that the reader recognizes.

I agree that covers on bookmarks become dated very quickly, but covers play a large role in catching my eye in book stores and in causing me to pick up a book. Even if a book is no longer available, I always appreciate a bookmark with a cover image included. It's visually appealing, and it's something that I associate specifically with that author. It might even encourage me to fire up my nook and search out the book from the author's backlist. I'm big on searching out backlist books when I find a new author whose voice appeals to me, so the cover could remind me to do that.

msullivan said...

JV, thank you for the awesome feedback!

Debra Salonen said...

Mary, I'm soooo impressed with the flower seed hearts. What a great idea and meaningful, too!

I've never attended a RomCon. I'm sorry I wasn't more receptive to the idea of attending a conference when the invitation to participate came in--in part because I wasn't going to have a current title to promote. But it sounds like a great conference. I look forward to hearing a recap.

I don't know what works, what people keep or if these items do anything for sales, but I love giving stuff away when I'm at a signing/conference. I've tried lots and lots of different things. The one thing I picked up from a goodie table that I use every day is a dog food can lid with the author's name on it. I hate to admit that I haven't read her books--and the guilt is killing me. ;-)

Deb

Julie Hilton Steele said...

I loved Morning Glory too and love the idea. I am big on those gripper things you use to open jars and potato chip bag clips. Useful things.

I saw a video of someone signing a kindle cover since they didn't have the traditional paperback. That got me wondering about the future of bookmarks.

I know some authors are now doing "trading cards" but until those are all over the place, I am not sure about how many folks will be into them.

So what would be good swag for those who have e-readers? I have listed some general things non-book related but am scratching my head. Custom kindle sleeves for prizes? A card with upcoming books so they can be put in the queue at Amazon and BandN pre-order or a list of all the backlist books now available by the author? I have noticed a number of authors now have books from long ago coming out on Kindle.

Have fun!

Peace, Julie

Kristina Mathews said...

Mary,
I love the idea of the recycled manuscript. How clever. I don't know that I would plant the flowers, since I tried to grow zucchini once and failed.

As a reader, I have to say the most enticing promos are the blogs. Especially when I read something personal that makes me think "Oh my gosh there are people just like me- they're writers!"

I read BEYOND ORDINARY while on vacation. I couln't put it down, even though it started raining out on the lake and I had to hide under a beach towel to keep from getting the pages wet.

msullivan said...

Deb, that dog food lid is a great idea! I've never even seen those on promo websites. But I know what you mean about feeling guilty! I have pens and sticky notes from authors whose books I've never purchased. The guilt isn't strong enough to make me go out to purchase their work, though ;-)

msullivan said...

Julie, yes, both the grippers and chip bag closers are great because they can be used over and over again, and won't just get tossed into the garbage!

You're right, though, that promo will probably look different in the future, won't it?

msullivan said...

Kristina, I figure that, if people don't want to grow the flowers themselves, they might pass the hearts along to people who would. Even if they end up in the garbage, there will be pretty flowers brightening landfills. Ha!

Yes, blogs are wonderful tools, aren't they?

I love your feedback about BEYOND ORDINARY. It got fewer stars in Romantic Times Book Review magazine than on my past books and wondered if the book wasn't as good as the others. I was a little disappointed. It's impossible for me to judge my own work, so it's wonderful to get positive feedback from a reader! Thank you ;-)

Nola Cross ~ Expect Romance! said...

Hello Mary: I just love the idea of the homemade paper impregnated with flower seeds. What a creative idea. Lots of wonderful ideas here. I'm bookmarking this post. Thank you.

Joan Leacott said...

HI Mary, Your homemade paper is a fabulous idea! I have a huge pile of pens I collected from Dallas National that I'm still working through. The same goes for bookmarks, so I no longer pick up those two items at conferences. I usually pass on food items as I expect them to be not very good. The t-shirt/tote bag combo would be a really cool door prize. They'd be longer-lived if they focused on your brand rather than a given title.

autumnmacarthur.com said...

That paper-heart-with-flower-seeds is such a cool idea. Really lovely! Using a rejected manauscript is a nice way to say goodbye to it and let it becaome something more beautiful- I love that symbolism.

I like useful promo items like pens, notebooks, and calendars, and will pick them up if I need them, but I won't take them just because they are there. Something pretty and unusual is more likely to catch my eye.

The problem with promo items from the author's point of view is that they get an author some name recognition, but they don't necessarily make me buy a writer's books.

Not at all.

Best promo ever to make me buy a book- getting to know the writer and liking her or her writing. Whether through a blog post, a lecture, talking face-to-face, or reading an excerpt.

Karina Bliss said...

Mary, I don't have any ideas to additional suggestions, though excerpt chapters usually entice me to buy. But I wanted to say how creative your ideas were...absolutely love your shredding and flower seeding your rejected ms. You go, girl!

Karina

Marcie said...

I agree with Karina - first chapter booklets that showcase one or two of your books. Harlequin sends these to entice people to join their Reader Service.

I love pens the most of all the promo I've received. T-shirts are cool, but not sure the cost-effectiveness of those.

Jackie S. said...

I think you have great ideas, Mary!! And love those Pilot pens!! Am anxious to read your book!

Joan Kilby said...

Mary, I love the seed heart. It sounds like a lot of work but it means something. I hope you've written somewhere on it just what you've done so that people who pick it up know what it represents. I don't go to many conferences so I mostly give away backlist books. Obviously there's a limit to how many of those you can give out. I've never bought a book because of a pen or bookmark.I've bought on the basis of reading a little excerpt booklet though.

msullivan said...

Thank you, Nola!

Joan, I agree with your thoughts about focusing on a brand rather than one title for something as long-lasting as a t-shirt.

Vicki Essex said...

Great post, Mary! I was struggling with spending money on promotional items, but you've shown that with a little creativity, you can make some really awesome promo products!

msullivan said...

Autumn, I have the same concern about promotional items--they don't necessarily inspire a reader to purchase a book and, yet, they are part of the 'business' of this career and I feel that readers expect to receive them at conferences. I can only hope that good will goes as far with readers as in other areas of life--and that readers will give my writing a chance.

msullivan said...

Thanks for the support, Karina! I couldn't imagine a better way to use up copies of an old manuscript taking up too much space in my closet ;-)

msullivan said...

Marcie, I like the excerpt booklets, too. They often do entice me to buy. They're a bit pricey for me at this stage in my career, but I won't rule them out for the future!

msullivan said...

"Am anxious to read your book!"

Thank you, Jackie ';-)

msullivan said...

Joan, in the balance between time and money, I definitely have more time than money!

Thank you, Vicki ;-)

chey said...

I like your recycled manuscript with flower seeds to plant. I think that would make me remember you the next time I went book shopping. The little books of excerpts might introduce me to a story I just have to read, so I'll go looking for it.
I use the mug, emery boards, books and tote bags I've won.

msullivan said...

Chey, it sounds like you've won good stuff ;-)

Anonymous said...

Hi Mary! First I have to say I love the story about your mom introducing you to romance, because my mom did the same for me. And like you I not only read it, but I write it too, well I try to, lol! I love your ideas with the manuscript and the flower seeds and the cookies too. All of the women have given good ideas too. My favorites are the things that hang around, like pens and bookmarks. I like the chip clip idea too. The other thing I like too is getting to read the first chapter from a new author before I have to buy. Of course almost every time I end up buying, but thats the point right, lol!

Hope you have a wonderful night!

Alina

Snookie said...

Mary, promotional items don't mean a lot to me. I do appreciate the one's people send me, but I don't usually use them. I like the bookmarks, not because I use them but most of them have titles from the author and like JV once I find an author I like, I'm looking for back books for my ereader :) I like blurbs about books, but i'm thinking those excerpt booklets must be expensive to print and if you're printing a hundred of them... not sure it's worth the time. I think ehar has a good forum to learn about authors. Especially their online reads. I've found new authors through the online reads and have looked for their back books and upcoming books. I also like being able to talk to the authors on some of the blog sites and Facebook :)

ClaudiaGC said...

Promo items don't make me buy a book. As I'm in Europe I've never attended a conference or met an author. So, I never was in the situation to first see the promo items and then maybe thinking about buying the book. But even if that would be the case, I still wouldn't buy a book because of promo items. They are nice present and souvenir, though.

msullivan said...

Alina, thanks for sharing that your mom started you on romance, too!

Snookie, the excerpt booklets are too pricey for me at this time, but I do like receiving them, especially if the writing is good! Then, yes, I do buy. But most of the time, I'm like ClaudiaGC, not inclined to buy just because someone gave me a free goodie.

Snookie said...

Mary, I would probably read the excerpt booklet if I got it, but wouldn't necessarily buy the book. I like that you can read excerpts on Amazon, Barnes and Noble, ehar. I just usually search for author or book title if I have it and read the excerpts before deciding to buy. The neat thing about those sites is that they always have an if you liked this book you might like these. So I click and check out excerpts on them. I've found new authors that way too!

Tammy Yenalavitch said...

Mary,

I am an easy sell. A free paper bookmark would get me to buy your book. Actually, I would buy your book without a gift being offered.

Kaelee said...

Hi Mary ~ Promo items don't make me buy a book but reading a good blog about the author or book might. I am a book reader so bookmarks do come in handy as do pens. The nicest promo item I ever received was a book bag that Jessica Hart sent me. I like using it as it's not a store specific bag. I have no idea about the cost of such an item. You can see the bag here: http://community.eharlequin.com/content/kaelees-outed-booksigning

Laura Russell said...

Hi Mary,
The cookies with your label are a great idea. I would enjoy them and remember your name, but I wouldn't need to hang on to something or feel guilty about tossing it.
I do keep lots of bookmarks - small ones that are the right size for category romance- and the ones with covers are actually more helpful even though they do get dated quickly. I leave extras at our local library. Then odds and ends I hang onto: a great emery board, post-it notes. Pens are always useful.

I think the sample chapters should be useful, but so far I haven't bought a book after reading one. I do read first few pages when I am deciding what to get.

Your paper hearts are so creative- another great idea.