By Sarah Mayberry
This time next year, I am hoping that I will be standing in my new kitchen, looking out over my new living/dining room. I know that planning things 12 months out might seem a little excessive, but I suspect I am going to need all the intervening time to finalise all the choices me and my man need to make in order to get this renovation happening.
When we bought our house twelve months ago, we did so with the knowledge that we wanted to extend. I wanted to do a little extension - just adding on a medium-sized extra living space - but my husband was adamant. “If we’re breaking ground, we might as well go all the way”, he said. I’m not sure where he got this “breaking ground” catchphrase from, but it’s been bandied about quite a bit in our household lately. After some to-ing and fro-ing, we finally agreed (ie I caved in) that the more generous extension would be better value.
So. Sometime next year we will be adding a 10m x 6 m “box” (approx 32’ x 20’) to the back of our existing house. It will be attached to the current kitchen so that the kitchen will look out over the large open plan space. Our current living and dining spaces, which are connected via a wide archway (much less elegant than it sounds!) will become our library/office and writing room. Just writing the words “writing room” gets me excited. This space will be about 6m by 4m (approx 20’ x 13’) and will feature my Chinoiserie chaise lounge (a magnificent folly of a piece of furniture that I bought while we were living in New Zealand which has since plagued us to death because it is so BIG), and me and my man’s writing set ups. It will be spacious
and light and bright and soooo much nicer than any of the tiny little rooms I have been jammed into over the years. In case you can’t tell, I cannot wait to be in this space.

The new living and dining spaces will essentially be a big rectangle. The wall facing the yard will feature at least 3 sets of French doors to give us an outlook onto the pool and garden, really bringing the outside in to our home. At one end of the rectangle we will have an open fireplace with more French doors either side of it that will lead to our outdoor entertaining area.
I have so many ideas for how this new space might look, but as I start to gather information and costs I am beginning to realise that most of my wildest fantasies will go by the wayside. We are not millionaires, after all, and some sacrifices will have to be made. For example, the beautiful French Provincial style carved sandstone mantelpiece on the right is probably not going to make it into the final spec. It’s way too expensive, and as much as I love it the indulgence is not worth sacrificing lots of other things.

The kitchen is the area where we are going to have to make the most decisions, I think. I have been trawling real estate pages and decorating magazines for months now, grabbing images of kitchens that I love. Finally, after months of debating and looking and wondering, I think we have finalised the “look” for our new kitchen. We are going to go for very simple “Shaker” style doors and drawers. We will have a large island bench/counter, and I plan on stealing a couple of the design ideas from this kitchen - see the big old ice box hinges and latches on the island cupboard doors? We love these, and I have already found a supplier on line who can get these to us. It’s a bit different, but also subtle and we think it will be a great design feature, along with the metal base caps on the “pillars” of the island. So, basically, we are rather shamelessly going to "steal" the look of this island bench/counter.
We would like to be slightly daring with color in our kitchen and are going to go with a black island bench/counter and white cabinetry on the wall. We will have a “chimney breast” style mantel above the freestanding oven to vent cooking smells

outside, and we will use a common bench top material/color to unite the island bench and the wall cabinetry. To the right is a picture of another kitchen that has used the black and white idea and which I am using as my inspiration.
I would love to have carrera marble counter tops, but all my research tells me that they are murder to maintain - they scratch, the surface is susceptible to acid etching, they stain. Someone on a blog I read claimed it was like having “a fourth child” to look after. Given I am not the neatest, most fastidious person in the world, I suspect carrera is not for me. So I am currently on the hunt for an alternative. There are a couple of engineered stone counter tops that mimic marble - my mission in the next few weeks will be to visit some showrooms and take a look at what this looks like on a large scale. If it looks good, I will be rapt - marble look + low maintenance = happy me!
Then there will be handles to choose, splashback tiles, tapware, sinks, etc, etc. We will need to wade through the myriad choices for door materials - vinyl wrap, melamine, 2-pac, solid timber, the list goes on - and start talking to kitchen companies about quotes. I was showing my friend all these ideas on the weekend and she told me my kitchen is going to cost $50,000. Needless to say, I nearly fell off my chair. I flat out refuse to pay so much for what amounts to a bunch of laminated timber. Maybe I’m tight, but spending the average person’s income on one room in a house strikes me as being crazy and unnecessary. So, I will be shopping around, sharpening my pencil and haggling with cabinetmakers and other tradespeople. I am a woman on a mission, and I am determined to prove that a beautiful kitchen does not need to cost an arm and a leg.
I would very much appreciate any tips, suggestions, warnings or advice you might have for me as we embark on this exciting project. Have you renovated a kitchen before? Are there things you would do differently the second time around? Are you planning your own renovation at some time in the future? I’d love to hear from you, and I will be giving away 2 books from my backlist, winner’s choice, to a random poster. Over to you!
46 comments:
Good Luck Sara, I know it will be beautiful. The most I remember about renovating a kitchen was about 30 years ago when we re-did the counter top and new sinks in our 90 yr old house. All went well until the sinks arrived, wrong size, of course the old ones were already pulled out, so I spent 2 weeks washing dishes in the bathtub! The end result was worth it, but strange how I only remember washing dishes in bathtub lol.
Never done any renovating, Sarah, but I'm excited for you! Have fun with it! And make sure you post pics when it's all finished.
Ah, kitchen renovations. I remember when we got our first home and I had to plan it all out...fun, horrific times.
I got everything at Ikea, and planned and measured it out on my own. Family helped with the installation. It's definitely cheaper that way, but if you're willing to splurge, get a professional to install it.
IMO, the two places you want to invest money in are your kitchen and your bathroom because those fixtures and finishes are much harder to change (tiles, cabinets, etc). So you should pick what your want and, to cut costs, think about cheaper alternatives that look the same. Home Depot is great for that.
Best of luck! It'll look fabulous and it'll be worth every penny.
Good luck, Sara! I think you're smart to start planning so far ahead. We remodeled our kitchen and put in hardwood floors several years ago, and figuring out exactly what we wanted was the hardest part. Once we made those decisions, the rest was mostly organizational. We did the tear-down work ourselves - floors, cabinets, counters - to save money. It was hard work, but worthwhile. And I'm still in love with my new kitchen.
Only one thing I'd do differently - I foolishly chose a cheaper sink, and I'm still kicking myself.
Make sure you post pictures when you're finished!
Never re-did a kitchen before, but general construction tips when the inside of our house was being completed, check on progress every day (look at every nick and cranny). Mistakes made that day are easier to fix than having to go back afterwards.
Also, change out ALL your air filters in the house as soon as everything is done.
Have a blast and can't wait to see the photos!
Good luck, Sarah. You have some great ideas, and I am sure it will all be beautiful. Keep us posted with pictures. Never done redo's, but have built 3 homes; this last time really downsized and wanted less maintenance (but convenience)!!
Hi Sarah--we redid our kitchen when I was pregnant. The fridge and microwave were hooked up, but they were in the garage where the contractor had his crew working. I'd squeeze my enormous bulk through the workers 3-4 times an hour on my way to the fridge because I was constantly starving. Sigh. I'd have killed for a bit of dignity. ;-)
My advice is pay for a professional kitchen designer. It's a very small cost compared to the overall budget, but the couple of hours that the professional put into envisioning the space and drawing up the plans took our kitchen from "fine" to "amazing." She knew things about space, light, and kitchen use that made a huge difference.
Maybe you and your hubby have that knowledge, but if not, the designer was totally worth the money.
When our kitchen was done, it was gorgeous, but we sold our house shortly afterward. We needed to move to a more walkable spot so our kids could do neighborhood things. I miss my old kitchen...and I don't even like to cook. It was just pretty.
I loved your pictures. Have a terrific time. I can't wait to see the finished project! We all want a peek at the writing space, too!
I had to lie down just after reading your post. The thought of redoing/renovating/remodeling exhausts me. My husband and I have been talking about a kitchen remodel in our home for years, but two things hold us back: the thought of the inconvenience and the cost. Every time we think we've saved enough money to actually consider it, something else in life goes haywire, and we wind up spending all the money we've saved plus some extra to fix it. Well, that and the fact that I'd have to do some major cleaning before I could let the workmen in the house!
For example, a few years ago, our rental property was vacated (forcibly), and the guy who'd lived there for several years had done a real number on it. (For example, he threw all of his trash up into the attic for reasons unknown and had drilled through our wrought iron pillars on the porch to bolt a plastic dinosaur head to it. Among other things. Go figure!)
We couldn't really afford to have everything redone that needed to be, and our daughter had a friend with little money who needed a place to live, so we decided to just have the house electricity rewired (the old wiring was bald in the attic and just not safe), clean up some, and let him rent it for cheap with the understanding that it wouldn't be the Taj Mahal.
Well, rewiring a tiny, two-bedroom house cost us $6,600. Then, a couple of years later, we had insulation blown in to make it more liveable about the same time he discovered <> bedbugs there. Getting rid of the unwanted visitors and the insulation cost us $1,600. This spring, we've had several serious thunderstorms, and he discovered when he opened the door to the second bedroom that he used only for storage that the roof had leaked and caved in the ceiling of the storage room and buckled the flooring. Now, we've looking at another $6,000+ to repair the roofing, the ceiling, and the flooring.
So, I guess that keeps me from having to worry about any pesky remodeling projects at home for a bit longer!
In all seriousness, Sarah, as far as I'm concerned, having a usable, liveable kitchen can make all the difference in how comfortable you'll be in your new home. Sounds like you're approaching it all well and realistically. Good luck!
My advice is to pay attention to appliances - make sure to get a big sink with upgraded capabilities like the touch feature or a faucet that can pull out and switch sprays. I also wish I had a cook's faucet over my stove. That would keep me from waddling to the stove with a huge pot of water. I'd recommend a convection oven and a 'fridge that's bigger than what you think you need.
My last kitchen had tile - my current granite. Granite is much easier to keep clean and the darker color hides spills, etc.
I really like the clean lines you have going and love the contrast between the white and black. I'm thinking you're going to be happy with that choice because ten years down the road, you can change accent colors and feel like you've a whole new look without changing any of the basic design. The fridge hardware is a nice artsy touch, too.
Congrats and enjoy the process :)
Liz Talley (who is still having problems logging in!)
Been down that road. We added an eighteen by about twenty eight addition on to our house years ago. New living room, bath and laundry room. Totally remodeled the old part of the house. Tore out the old bath to make Kitchen bigger, lived in a mess for several years because we did most of the work ourself. Would I have done thing different, yes. I would have just built a new house behind this one, so I wouldn't have to live in the mess so long. Its an ok house but it still needs to be bigger at least the bedrooms need to be bigger.
Your kitchen sounds incredible. Green with envy here in my tine house. I do agree that adding the bigger room now instead of later is wise.
We are constantly remodeling. I sleep with the contractor. Saves money. ;-) It helps that he's my husband.
A good design is important--particularly if you're installing new cabinets. I highly recommend recessed can lighting. Solar tubes and/or passive solar if at all possible. You won't regret spending a little extra on a great sink.
The mess in unavoidable. My niece washed dishes in the bath tub for two months while her kitchen was being redone.
From a contractor's point of view: know your own taste going in. Don't visualize a Cadillac if your budget says Volkswagon. Expect it to take longer and cost more than you think it will. (It's human nature to add stuff into the process during the project because you tell yourself you're never going to do this again.)
Good luck and have fun.
Deb
LOL-Sarah when can I come visit?
Is this a do it yourself project? All I remember from our kitchen remodel is that it took longer and cost more than planned. Oh, and I went for awhile wihtout a stove. My son did a beautiful job on the tile work (I had him copy the pattern from a showroom display).
The deck was supposed to be a continuation of that remodel. Were are going on 3 years without "real" steps out the back door because the deck project never got off the ground after the time and money spent on the kitchen.
Save time and money hire a professional .
Sarah
Hi Sarah,
We're planning on remodeling our kitchen sometime soon. Our house was built in 1997 and we just want to update, but the headache and mess is holding me back.
Love your ideas and the black and white motif. I'm getting in the mood. *g*
Linda Warren (who's having problems posting too)
Hmmmm, guess it's not just me having problems posting. I'm thinking it must be google blogger that just won't recognize us anymore.
Sarah, good luck!!! I think you should hire a professional to at least review your plans. They understand use patterns and lighting and can make very helpful suggestions. When you sink that much money into a project you want to make sure it meets your needs and your budget. Your ideas sound like your kitchen/dining area will be beautiful when it's done. I love the idea of it opening out to your open space/pool/garden.
Snookie (who can no longer log in with my google account).
Sarah, I envy you *g* I would love to redo our kitchen but I'm afraid it'll have to wait another year or so. Maybe I should start planning now, huh?
Enjoy the process :-)
Wow, Sarah, it sounds wonderful, especially the French windows and the open fireplace. The writing space sounds even more wonderful!
Right now my "writing space" is sitting cross legged on our bed, and my kitchen is about the size of that chaise longue of yours! Not complaining, I love our tiny house, but renovating tips from me are more likely to have to do with how to get by in 400 square feet total house area!
I would say, put in the biggest fridge you can. Also really look at work flow in the kitchen. With a big space, it's tempting to spread the cooking and food preparation areas out too much and your feet will thank you if you plan these to be close together and use the space for seating areas so the cook can talk to the guests/ non-cook.
Most of all, enjoy the whole process and enjoy your renewed house!
I think you're smart to be working on your plans already. I haven't redone my kitchen, but have heard from others who have that it's really expensive to change your plans after the renovations start. Good Luck!
Why is Google so messed up? I am Anonymous again - Sarah, you already know I love your books and I love you kitchen ideas. I have never done a kitchen renovation before - I hope all goes well with your renovation.
Tammy Yenalavitch - aka Tammy Y
It's not strictly a Google blogger issue, because I'm using Google blogger to log in successfully.
I've never done any renovating. My cousin and her husband like to do stuff with their house. They're planning to rip out the carpet and put new floorboards in.
Hi everyone. Thanks so much for your enthusiasm and advice. To everyone who has suggested a professional kitchen planner, we have already gone down that route. For reasons that are way to complicated to explain on paper, we could not for the life of us work out how to make our kitchen work with the ideas we had and the space on offer. We argued and had ideas and then found problems with our ideas. My aunt had a great kitchen designer, so we got him. It cost us $1000, but he totally solved all our issues so I now have plans I can take around to various kitchen places and cabinet makers to start my haggling process and cost things out. I feel much more confident knowing that our plans are "professionally endorsed", if you know what I mean. On the appliances front, we already have a really big fridge, but in my heart of hearts I'd love a French door fridge (not sure if they are as popular in US as here, but they look great and I love the double door feature) Might have to wait to see what's left in the kitty when this is all over and see if we can swap out the fridge. I have been eyeing off this incredibly expensive very deep, square double sink with drainer. It's nearly $3000, and that is so not going to happen. A bit of shopping around, and I have found a sink that offers similar bowl depth but not quite the same sharp, very square modern lines - I can live with that, I think. Like the fireplace, I'm not willing to make all the sacrifices just for the look. I will not be scrimping on my freestanding oven/stove, however. I want a big one - 90 cm (35") with an oven that can take more than just my roasting pan. Will be in heaven when I have it. Bliss!
Hey Sarah! I love your inspiration photos. If there's any room in a house worth turning into your dream room, it's the kitchen. I love granite and stainless steel, but most of all I love extra large center islands.
I'd love to see before and after pics! You could do a post here and call it 'Kitchen Re-visions'. Sorry...I couldn't resist the play on words ;).
I haven't down a renovation project but I have bought new appliances. I just love my true convention oven. My sister on the other hand got some kind of partial convection oven and hates it.
I'm using a Google sign in as well. Every once in a while it makes me sign in again and I have lost posts.
Hi everyone. Sorry about the problems with the blog - not sure what's going on there at all. I am so tech challenged that I am not sure I will even be able to find the right place to look for an answer to our woes, but I will go on the hunt anyway... I will be more than happy to share before and after photos. Suspect it will be pretty profound - current kitchen is very dated and pokey, and by the time we've opened things up etc, it's going to be all kinds of awesome. Kaelee, I have to ask what a true convection oven is - I didn't realise there were different types. I'm looking at a Smeg oven which is dual fuel - ie gas cooktop and electric oven.
Okay, just found this over at a blogger issues site:
We're investigating an issue which is preventing login and comment posting for some users, and hope to have a fix released shortly.
Thanks for your patience in the meantime. — LATEST UPDATE ON TUESDAY, MAY 24, 2011
So, fingers crossed these glitches will soon be a thing of the past...
HI Sarah! Your ideas sound wonderful. As for the french door fridge, yes they are very popular here too. We just got one and its huge and I love it! We haven't done any renovating yet, but we are planning some right now. We are adding an office for my husband, which I will of course use all the time, lol! Plus we are going to finish my daughters room and I plan to put in a closet under our stairs. Thats about it for now, but it scares me already, lol!
Good Luck with your renovations and let us know how it turns out! Have a great day!!!
Alina
hi alina - it is scary, isn't it, making all those decisions and spending all that money. A part of me keeps asking if we really need all this stuff, but I know that the house will be worth a lot more by the time we're finished, so it's actually a good investment for the future. I'm so not looking forward to the disruption and mess. There's a woman up the road who has a guest apartment that she rents out by the week for holiday makers, and I have been eyeing her accommodation off and thinking that when things get really messy - when the water gets cut off etc, etc - it might pay for us to move out of the house for a month or so while things get sorted. I could still come to the house every day to work and act as project manager, but it might mean we stay marginally more sane than not...
Hi Sarah,
I like Ellen's idea of a professional kitchen designer. My sister found one so helpful with those details. She recommended a composite instead of marble that worked well. Looks similar, not a maintenance sink.
The photos are quite monochromatic, but you said you're going for color- that's nice to hear.
Good luck with those decisions.
Hi Laura. We're thinking of a green or red splashback. I have seen these hand glazed italian tiles that have this lovely almost water color look to them (a sort of non-uniform color consistency, if that makes sense, because of the hand glazing), with crackled glazing etc. I quite like the idea of that pop of color against the black and white. But it's going to be a matter of finding those suckers. That's the problem of looking at decorator magazines - not only are the rooms on show about a gazillion times more expensive than most ordinary people can afford, half the time the items featured are so obscure that it's impossible to replicate the look. But I've got a year to hunt things down, right?
JV, it is a google blogger problem. I too have successfully signed in when others have not been able too. Now it's not letting me sign in at all, just wants to keep me anonymous.
Sarah, great to hear that you did contact a designer. Your space is going to be so beautiful when it's done! You'll have to post pictures.
That last anonymous post was me, Snookie :) I also forgot to mention that when I remember I copy my post before I try to post, in case it decides to get lost in the ether :)
Snookie, not sure if you saw my post above, but this signing in thing is a known blogger issue and they're trying to fix it at the moment. I don't know if that means we have to do anything (like apply a patch or something) but I will keep checking in to see what folks are saying about it. And I'm so going to post pictures. I am going to be as obnoxious as hell with pictures...
I have renovated both bathroom and kitchen. I remembering crying a lot because nothing was as I had dreamed. My advice: measure, measure, measure.
marypres@gmail.com
Oh, good advice, Mary. We'll be using tradespeople for everything except the donkey work - the ripping stuff out stage - but I totally get how the fabulous vanity I fall in love with might, you know, smack into the toilet bowl if I get my math wrong. Will be double checking everything, don't worry!
Never done a whole kitchen.
But I once helped paint the doors on kitchen cabinets. They where treated with a sort of finishing that didn't mix well with the paint so when painting the doors sand them down first.
Also make sure the surrounding where you paint are hoovered and dusted. No stuff flying about. For sure it'll stick to the new doors. And then you can start over again. You don't want that funny texture.
Hey Sarah, I'm one of those having trouble getting onto comments. I have one of those extra width ovens and highly recommend them. Nothing like getting the apple pie next to the roast...but who knows what happened to warming drawers? Good luck with your renovations.
Karina
Hi Jo's daughter. I am having this rich, very detailed fantasy where I won't have to paint anything in the new kitchen because all our quotes will be so affordable... But just in case have made note of your advice. I had that dust-sticking-to-wet-paint thing happen before. What a pleasure!
Hi Karina. What is going on with Blogger today? Craziness! Good to hear my oven lust is warranted. I'm not sure what I'd do with a warming drawer... Keep my behind warm in cold weather, perhaps? (apologies for bad gag - it's been a long writing day and my fingers are worn down to stubs)
No advice, just jealousy here :) I've been doodling kitchen renovation ideas since about 6 months after we moved into our house (11 years ago). I have recently come to the conclusion that we should just move because 1) existing kitchen lacks sufficient footage for what I want 2) We lack lot space in which to expand and 3) We shall already be lucky to sell house in its for its current value due to surrounding area and making the house more expensive will be counterproductive (or rather, gifting the next owner a fancy new kitchen that they won't be willing to pay us for).
In preparation for selling, I've been having fun spiffing up light fixtures and cleaning out the pantry and we put in some nicer (but not too nice) appliances to make the existing kitchen look appealing to a potential buyer.
I hope your project goes well and that the kitchen of your dreams is, well, dreamy :)
Kristi, good luck with selling your house! Fingers crossed for you, and who knows, next time round you may buy a house with the perfect kitchen and not have to worry about a renovation...
I agree with Debra and Ellen re getting a professional contractor. I would like to add that you should keep interviewing them until you get the one who will do what YOU want. My SEVENTEENTH contractor agreed to do what I wanted, per my drawings. Most only offered pre-made cabinets, but I wanted custom-made so I could utilize every square inch in my tiny kitchen. The company I finally hired not only did what I asked, but made suggestions that might improve my kitchen - and DID!
So my advice to you is to find someone to do it YOUR way and not THEIR way. It may take awhile, but it is well worth the wait.
BTW, my job was to take 1 week and took 2.5 weeks. Way back in 1998 it was to cost $11,000 + taxes and ended up being $14,000 + taxes. Worth every penny and wait. My kitchen is still beautiful and perfect for a family of tall people. Our counters are 3" higher than "normal", we have cupboards that open in our kitchen AND dining room, our cupboards go to the ceiling, there are shelves in our new pantry (previously a closet) rather than drawers so we can fit more stuff on them easily, a new electrical panel and outlets ensure appliances don't blow fuses/breakers, lights are everywhere, our "triangle" works well, and they used original trim previously from our closet to improve the window sill but still match the rest of our house. Who could ask for anything more?
Laney4
Great advice, Laney. It's been noted. I watch lots of home make over shows on the Living channel, especially Grand Designs, and I am well aware that everything costs more and takes longer. One of the things we want to do is make sure we nail down the "known" costs early up - materials/appliances, essentially - and stick to our decisions about finishes etc. One of the reasons we're starting our planning now is to really think about things. And talking about it with friends, etc, and getting them to throw their two cents in. Your kitchen sounds great. I have tall friends who had a tall kitchen made - I feel like I need a step stool in their house, since I am only 5'2"!
Ah, kitchen design! One of the last mysteries of mankind! lol I feel with you, Sarah. It's so hard to make a final decision on everything because it costs so much money and you don't want to spend your money useless. We've only done our kitchen last year, so I can still sympatise with you. :) I'm the cook in my family so it was basically my decision what appliances I needed and which not. But oh, these kitchen studios tempt you with lots of shiny things you probably use only once in a while but cost you a fortune. I'm really happy now with my kitchen and haven't found any faults with it so far. A friend of mine for expample wanted a steamer at all costs and now she has realized she barely uses it! To much of a bother, she says! The thing I really wanted were higher counters but a lower cooker (more back friendly) and I'm not regretting that. So, good luck with planning your new kitchen, maybe we can see some pictures in the future! :)
Sarah,
I kept one long counter at regular height JUST for my shorter friends (and for resale value, what can I say).
Hi Claudia. I am a little scared of the kitchen showrooms. I'm going to start shopping my plans around soon, and I know they are going to try to tempt me with shiny pull out things and soft close doors and other things I probably haven't even imagined. I am going to be disciplined. I swear I am. No, really...
Laney, you're too clever. A great idea. On behalf of short people everywhere, I thank you!
Post a Comment