Tuesday, March 8, 2011

Where Did You Get That Idea?


One of the questions I get most frequently from non-writers is 'where do you get your ideas?' People are fascinated by the idea of making up stories from nothing – and being able to do it again and again. My personal favorite answer to that question is from Susan Elizabeth Phillips, one of my favorite authors. When someone asks her that question, she smiles and says, 'from a warehouse in Tulsa.' Although I wish I was as quick and clever as Susan, my usual answer is an uncomfortable shrug and an 'uh, they just sort of come to me.'
Most of the time, that's the best I can do. An idea might be triggered by something I read in the newspaper, or a snippet of a conversation I overheard at a restaurant or store. Yes, all you non-writers out there, be careful. Writers love listening to other people's conversations. There's nothing as fascinating as other people's lives. This is, perhaps, because our lives mostly consist of sitting in front of a computer and staring into space.
But I digress. When I can actually pinpoint where the idea came from, I remember it forever. My March Superromance, For Baby and Me, is one of those books.
A couple of years ago, when I had to get downtown early on a weekday, I took the commuter bus from my neighborhood to the train station. It was very early – around 7 AM – and I hadn't yet had my caffeine hit. So I was sort of bleary-eyed, and when the bus arrived, I plopped into the first seat I saw. Sitting across from me was a very pregnant woman.
I immediately began wondering about her – where she worked, if she had to walk from the train station into the Loop (a good six or seven blocks), if she had other kids at home, etc, etc. From there, I began to wonder other things – did she like her job and was she looking forward to her maternity leave? Was she a single mother? If so, did she have family in the area, or was she completely on her own? You writers know how that goes. I just couldn't help myself.
The questions lingered, and they eventually morphed into Sierra and Nick's story in For Baby and Me. I wish I could thank the woman, but I never saw her again. I would have liked to tell her that her baby sparked the creation of my baby.
Writers, what do you tell people when they ask where you get your ideas? Do you wish there was a warehouse in Tulsa? Readers, what in a story draws your interest and sucks you into a book? I'll enter everyone's answers into a drawing for my last two books, Can't Stand the Heat? and Life Rewritten (I know where that idea came from, as well. Two in a row!).

43 comments:

Kristin Noel Fischer said...

Margaret, I love hearing how a complete stranger gave you the idea for "For Baby and Me." It's so interesting that a random person can spark an idea for an entire book. I bet if you met her, you'd find that her life was completely different from what you imagined.

My best ideas seem to come when I least expect them. Sitting in church, watching a tennis match, pushing my cart down the cereal aisle at HEB...

"Where do I get my ideas?" I think the question I'd like to have answered is, "Why do I have all these ideas and feel so compelled to make up stories about innocent strangers?" It's not normal, is it?

Laney4 said...

Hey there! Thanks for sharing! My favourite part of a book is "witty dialogue". It draws me in and I turn pages even faster than usual. I recently read a book while waiting to see a doctor in a clinic, and I LOL several times. I'm sure people stared at me. I tried to keep my laughs/chortles to myself, but finally decided to heck with it! And I enjoyed it even more from that point on!

Kaelee said...

I have already won these two books from you so no need to enter my name in the draw. Thank you!

A lot of different things pull me into a book. I like a laugh or two as I read so as Laney4 said witty repartee is a winner. Setting can sometimes make me buy the book. I like to travel as I read so a new location is fun. I learn a lot about North America and the rest of the world as I use google for pictures and facts. Then I have some favorite authors whose style of writing just lifts me up. They write stories with soul in them.

I can understand how listening in on a conversation might spark a book. I have no ambition to write and that happens to me. I want to know how the story ends. Thanks for writing the books that give me a HEA.

Margaret Watson said...

Kristen, you have all those ideas and are compelled to make up stories about strangers because you're a writer. Other writers would say, 'well, duh'. It's just other people who give you funny looks and edge away a little if you tell them.

Laney, I love witty dialogue, too. And I bet at least one of those people in the waiting room snuck a peek at your book and went out and bought it. I certainly would.

Julie Hilton Steele said...

If an author takes a really difficult subject like cancer, abuse, or something out of the headlines and makes it an inspirational but REAL sort of read, I usually can't put those books down. Like Laney4 says, witty dialogue is a great way to keep me turning the pages.

Then there is the author who takes a theme or storyline that has been done over and over and then turns it into a whole new fresh storyline.

If I find an author who gets me out of my reading slump, I am theirs for life!

Peace, Julie

Virginia C said...

Hi, Margaret! I totally identify with your comments. More often I am an observer rather than a participant. I am a thinker and a dreamer more than a "doer". Many times my wonderings lead to stories that are written in my mind. No matter what I am reading, whatever genre, time frame, subject & etc., my interest is captured and held by the same elements: well-developed, involving characters and a detailed, interesting story line. It's really the skill of the storyteller that keeps me committed until the last word is read. I have my comfort reads, my "try something new" reads, and then every once in a while, I find a hidden gem. I absolutely love to find super surprise reads! A book that didn't sound or look totally promising but turns out to be so well-written that I can't put it down until I'm done! A reader's treat that makes me look for other works by the same author. I'll rifle through their backlist for more treasures : )

Autumn said...

As a reader, what draws me in is characters I care about, facing a believable and meaningful challenge.
As a writer, I wish I could get more of that into my stories! It always makes me laugh when I hear that the question most often asked of authors is "Where do you get your ideas?" Any writer could say that's not the problem, it's finding a big enough stick to fight off the ideas and characters than clamour to be written. And of course, holding on to the ideas and characters among that crowd who will actually make a good story!

Maybe I do need a key to that warehouse in Tulsa after all...

Anonymous said...

Hi Margaret! Well, I started reading a certain author because her name was the same as my maiden name and the titles of her books were topics I was dealing with in my life. Then when i actually read the books there were components in it that were "pieces of me, my life, or my journey"--it was uncanny and intriguing at the same time and so I started collecting her books.the other deb

Margaret Watson said...

Kaelee,I'm with you on location. I love a book that brings a new setting to life for me. It doesn't matter where it is - if the author can make it seem real and vibrant, I'm completely sucked in.

Julie, there's nothing more fun than finding a book that takes a tried and true plot and turns it upside down. Just like you, when I find that, they're on my list of auto-buys.

Virginia, for me it's the characters, too. Nothing hooks me more quickly than interesting, engaging characters. And if there's a great story to go along with them, I can't put the book down.

Autumn, that's always my first reaction when someone asks me where I get my stories - that I have too many stories and not enough time to tell them all. The brains of non-writers are clearly wired differently. They always look shocked when I say that.

Deb, there's nothing like making that kind of connection with a book and an author. It can be spooky sometimes!

jcp said...

Charaters and themes tend to draw me in.

Jackie S. said...

I love to read and really enjoy a book that starts off with a real "mystery"....then I can't put it down until I finish it and the mystery is solved!!

liztalley said...

I've always had a vivid imagination. When people meet me they usually ask "how do you write stories?". I usually respond with "I use to get spankings for telling stories. Now I get paid for them.". The thing is I've always made up stories in my head. I ask what if all the time. And that's where my stories cone from. What if.

liztalley said...

Sport about the typos. I'm at the doctor's office :)

EllenToo said...

What draws me into a story??? First there needs to be some kind of mystery and I don't necessarily mean the type of mystery you find in books like intrigue ~ although that fits in ~ but I need something that makes me want to read the rest of the book to find out how something ends.I guess I want something unpredictable as well.(does that make any sense??) I know all romances end with an HEA but it is the way they get there that makes me read a book to the end. And yes there have been books I put down and never finished.
PS. I have both of your books so don't enter me in the drawing.

msullivan said...

Margaret, lovely story about your inspiration for 'For Baby and Me.' It's funny where ideas can come from. For me, sometimes it's a newspaper article or a single lyric from a song. Sometimes, it's a timeworn cliche that I want to come at from a different angle. Once it was an incident on the beach, just watching the way a young man touched his girlfriend so, so sweetly. Mostly, it's anything that will spark a lot of 'what if' questions.

Gloria said...

Boy a hard question for me, what draws me to a book is unfortunately the cover, what keeps me reading and enjoying it is the characters and the believability of "this could really happen". I also have left lots of books unfinished, "can't tell a book by its cover". lol

Tammy Yenalavitch said...

Hi Margaret - Lots of things draw me into a book - humor - a mystery or something that is intriguing.

alinaduffer said...

Hi Margaret! As a reader I always wondered the same thing, where do they come up with these wonderful characters and ideas. As an aspiring writer I have learned that they, like you said, can come from anything and everything. Some of my ideas have come from songs or something I saw on tv or even something I heard someone say. I think thats why there are so many great books out there. You can give five amazing authors the same scene and they can all take it in completly different directions that end up being something totally amazing.

Have a wonderful day!!!

Margaret Watson said...

Jackie and Ellen, it's always the 'what's going to happen next' that draws me in. I do love mysteries and suspense, but for a lot of books, it's the 'what's going to happen next in the relationship'.

Hey, Liz and Mary, I'm another one of those who has always made up stories in my head. And the 'what if'. I can do the 'what if' all day.

Hi, Gloria, A great cover will catch my eye, but I rely more on the back cover copy to give me a sense of what the story is about. I'm afraid that I can be bought by the judicious use of buzz words.

Margaret Watson said...

Hi, Tammy, I love humor in books, too. I wish I could do it better!

Hey, Alina, one of my earlier books for Intimate Moments was inspired by a George Strait song - I Can Still Make Cheyenne. One of my favorite titles, too - Rodeo Man.

Anonymous said...

I have been asked where I get ideas and I say "I make them up". I'm not quick enough to come up with something witty.

As a reader, I get sucked in by the characters and what they are going through. If I pull for them to make it, then I'm engaged in the story.

Marcie

Debra Salonen said...

Verrrry interesting. The question gave me pause...and, yes, I wish there was a warehouse in Tulsa.

My current WIP started in the sauna. I was alone. I have no idea why the story entered my brain or where it came from. By the time the heater kicked off, I knew I had to get this on paper (metaphorically). I sat down at my computer and typed for hours--in my robe. Crazy writer type!

Deb

Margaret Watson said...

Hey, Deb, it sounds like it was a good idea if it kept you typing for hours. I can't wait to read it!

Helen Brenna said...

I usually can't remember where I get my ideas, either, but when I do I'm like you. Will never forget. People do tend to spark things for me. Seeing someone interesting. Like you with this pregnant woman on the train.

I think I love watching people even more than listening to them! We're nosy creatures, we writers! lol

scarlet wilson said...

I'm a back cover blurb girl too. And I get really disappointed if the back blurb doesn't really reflect the story. It happens more often than you'd expect!

JV said...

As soon as I can feel the emotion between the H & h, then I'm drawn in. Sometimes (rarely) I never really feel a connection that seems genuine. Those are the stories that really don't do it for me. Sometimes (most often), it builds slowly. Other times, something about the characters (whether it's a hint of vulnerability or something, like a lifetime of friendship, that easily makes me believe in their emotional connections) draws me right in, and I'm invested from the very beginning. I guess that's why I'm partial to the friends-to-lovers theme. The background is already there to support the transition to love. I don't have to make any logical leaps or stretches to believe that the emotion between them is real.

Rogenna Brewer said...

Margaret, I wouldn't be able to shoot off the cuff like SEP either :)

Ideas are everywhere. They come to me. That's the only way I know how to explain it .

Margaret Watson said...

Yeah, Helen, and don't you hate it when people catch you staring at them? Really embarrassing.

JV, I like the friends to lovers theme, too. I think you're right - it's the emotional connection between the couple that's already there.

Rogenna, sometimes, when people ask that question, I just shrug and say exactly that - they just come to me. Don't know where, don't know how.

Laura Russell said...

I haven't been asked that question yet :)
But I certainly listen in when I'm out in public. Some things come to me that feel important. Sometimes my characters lead me- they know what they want to do.

Lenora said...

Oh, I love this discussion. I often dream things that later become books. I've done that with several books. And I love to watch people. Once I was sitting in a Waffle House in Vicksburg on New Year's morning. We were traveling back to Louisiana. A distinguished looking older man came in, wearing a tuxedo. I thought "one day I have to put that in a book." I used that image later but my hero was younger and he'd been stabbed in the chest. I love taking two different articles and matching them up to create a plot. I've done that with several stories.

Kaelee said...

I've been thinking about this since I posted. I missed a very important thing that will get me to buy a book. I like heroes with unusual occupations. Joan Kilby's tax man is one the comes to mind but her ex- sports hero worked as well. I would love to see someone write an undertaker as either a hero or heroine as the two I know personally are both highly entertaining outside of their jobs and they both have families so they must have had a romance as well. I also like heroines with non conventional jobs like a blacksmith, plumber or electrician. At one point wine maker's held a fascination for me but there are quite a few books out with that occupation now. I think occupations go in cycles. I know sports heroes are not supposed to sell but I've always wondered what it was like to be a hockey player from some foriegn country trying to make it in the NHL and leaving family and friends and language behind. Maybe even ending up in a non hockey type place like Florida. How do they do it?

Margaret Watson said...

Kaelee, I like sports heroes a lot. I'll always pick up a book that features one. I wish there were more of them.

Snookie said...

I love witty dialog and strong heroines -- not overly strong, but heroines that will stand up for themselves, make the best of what they got, etc.

As to the seeing/hearing something and wondering about it, I do that too even though I'm not a writer! So I totally understand how you could get the spark for a story from a mundane bus ride to the train stop!

I too like heroes and heroines with non-conventional jobs. I especially like the super and suspense lines because they don't play on the (I think anyway) overused billionaire CEO or royalty. I'm not saying I don't like those, but I'd rather read about every day ordinary people like us :)

Linda Warren said...

Margaret,
I get ideas from people and the news, too. But most of the time they're just there. Sometimes when I'm asked that question I'll say, "I don't know and it's getting scary."

Linda

Beth Andrews said...

Margaret, my father recently asked me where I get my ideas *g* I usually tell people I'm not sure, that the ideas just come to me :-)

I do love to people-watch and I've gotten a few ideas from a news article or TV shows (with those I try to twist the premise to make it my own *g*)

Jacquie Biggar said...

Hi, Margaret, for me I love conflict and humor in a story.Life is often pretty serious which is why I look to great books to take me away for awhile.I love a book that can make me both laugh and cry through their storyline.Your right all of SEP's books are awesome,also I recently read Emily and Einstien by Linda Francis Lee, it was perfect!!

Jeannie Watt said...

Hi Margaret, my Literacy signing buddy--I rarely get asked where I get my ideas. Hmmm. Out of the loop. Anyway, I tend to build stories around people I find interesting, such as your pregnant woman. Sometimes I know them and sometimes I just see them and think, facinating person...must try to use her in a story. Fun conversation. I love hearing what the readers are looking for. Taking notes here...

Anita Joy said...

I get my ideas from all sorts of places, but like you, Margaret, it isn't usually much to trigger my imagination and the 'what if' questions.

I've used job adverts, overheard conversations, news articles, something I see... Story ideas seem to be everywhere :)

Renald said...

I have been reading Harlequin novels for years,since the 1980s.This is my first vist to this site.

marybelle said...

I'm not drawn in by any one particular thing. I want great characters & an interesting story line. The first sentence needs to 'grab' hold of me or at least the first page.

marypres@gmail.com

Karina Bliss said...

Margaret, your post goes to show ideas can come from a chance sighting on a bus. I usually get ideas from what if scenarios...what if your best friend called in a drunken marriage pact.
I also like challenges...twin swap story anyone?
(my next release).
Karina

ClaudiGC said...

Honestly, I can't really say what draws me into a story. I think it's a mixture of a lot of things like the setting, the time period or the plot itself (like friends-to-lover story or secind-chance or something like that)and sometimes maybe even the cover!
Good luck with your latest book!

linda s said...

I just had a credit card stolen. Have you any idea how many nightmares I could dream up of what became of it? One incident, so many possibilities.

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...